Maybe you've binged through all the true-crime documentaries available, or perhaps you're craving a quality film that puts your crime-solving skills to the test. Either way, if you're a fan of murder mystery movies, you're in for a treat!
Amazon Prime Video is a streaming service that boasts an incredible collection of gripping, edge-of-your-seat thriller movies that will keep you guessing until the very end. From psychological thrillers to classic whodunits, here are the ten best mystery movies on Prime Video right now.
10. Murder & Cocktails (2024)
When a neighbor on their floor is murdered, married couple Nick (Jason Bernardo) and Lana (Jessicah Neufeld) host a series of cocktail parties in their apartment to uncover which of their neighbors is the culprit. "Murder & Cocktails" masterfully intertwines suspense and social dynamics, crafting an engaging atmosphere where every guest is a potential suspect. With each gathering, secrets are unearthed, and the tension mounts, making this film a must-watch for mystery thriller enthusiasts who love piecing together clues—and sipping on fancy cocktails—alongside the characters.
9. Above Suspicion (2019)
Based on a true story, "Above Suspicion" follows the intense and dangerous relationship between a newly married FBI agent (Jack Huston) and a local informant (Emilia Clarke) in a small Appalachian town. As the lines between professional and personal blur, the consequences become deadly. Fans of murder mystery movies on Amazon Prime will appreciate the film's realistic portrayal of crime and corruption. With its strong performances and gripping storyline, "Above Suspicion" is a must-watch for those who enjoy true crime dramas.
8. Beyond a Reasonable Doubt (2009)
In this modern remake of the 1956 film, a journalist (Jesse Metcalfe) sets out to expose a corrupt district attorney (Michael Douglas) by framing himself for a murder he didn't commit. As his plan spirals out of control, he finds himself in a race against time to prove his innocence. The film's intricate plot and unexpected twists will keep you on the edge of your seat. Mystery thriller enthusiasts will love the clever interplay between truth and deception, making "Beyond a Reasonable Doubt" a standout thriller on Amazon Prime Video.
7. Old (2021)
From the mind of M. Night Shyamalan, "Old" is a chilling tale of a family who discovers a mysterious secluded beach that causes them to age rapidly. As they try to escape, they must uncover the beach's secrets before time—and their lives—run out. The film's eerie atmosphere and mind-bending twists make it a compelling watch all the way through. It's perfect for those who enjoy murder mystery movies on Amazon Prime with a supernatural twist.
6. Jagged Edge (1985)
"Jagged Edge" is a classic courtroom thriller that follows an attorney (Glenn Close) charged with defending a man (Jeff Bridges) accused of murdering his wife. As she delves deeper into the case, she begins to doubt her client's innocence. The film masterfully blends legal drama with suspense, keeping viewers engaged until the final verdict. With its compelling performances and tightly woven plot, "Jagged Edge" remains one of the best mystery movies on Amazon Prime.
5. The Bone Collector (1999)
Starring Denzel Washington and Angelina Jolie, "The Bone Collector" follows a quadriplegic detective (Washington) and his rookie police officer partner (Jolie) as they hunt a serial killer who leaves cryptic clues at his crime scenes. The film's clever puzzles and intense cat-and-mouse game make it a standout in the mystery genre. "The Bone Collector" is a must-watch for mystery thriller enthusiasts who enjoy solving complex cases alongside the protagonists.
4. Absence of Malice (1981)
In "Absence of Malice," businessman Michael Colin Gallagher (Paul Newman) becomes the target of a smear campaign when a reporter (Sally Field) publishes a story implicating him in a murder. As he fights to clear his name, the film explores themes of ethics in journalism and the power of the media. Its exploration of media manipulation and moral ambiguity makes it one of the best mystery movies on Amazon Prime and is sure to keep you guessing from start to finish.
3. Wind River (2017)
Set in the harsh landscape of a Wyoming Native American reservation, "Wind River" follows a wildlife tracker (Jeremy Renner) and an FBI agent (Elizabeth Olsen) as they investigate the mysterious murder of a young woman. The film's bleak setting and haunting storyline create a powerful atmosphere of suspense and intrigue. Fans of murder mystery movies on Amazon Prime will appreciate the film's emotional depth, stunning cinematography, and intense plot twists.
2. Charade (1963)
Starring Audrey Hepburn and Cary Grant, "Charade" is a classic mystery that blends romance and suspense, making it one of the best mystery movies on Amazon Prime. When a woman discovers her husband's murder, she becomes entangled in a web of deceit involving stolen money and multiple identities. The film's charming leads and witty dialogue make it a timeless favorite that is sure to captivate mystery lovers of all ages.
1. The Silence of the Lambs (1991)
In this iconic thriller, FBI trainee Clarice Starling (Jodie Foster) seeks the help of imprisoned cannibalistic serial killer Dr. Hannibal Lecter (Sir Anthony Hopkins) to catch another active serial killer, Buffalo Bill. The film's chilling atmosphere and unforgettable performances make it a standout in the mystery genre. Its masterful storytelling and intense suspense have rightfully earned it a place among the greatest films of all time.
Want More Murder Mystery in Your Life?
The thrill of a good mystery doesn't have to end when the credits roll. If you're looking for an interactive experience, hop aboard the Murder Mystery Dinner Train in Fort Myers, Florida. You'll enjoy a delicious five-course meal as you work to solve a live-action mystery. Book your tickets now and get ready to immerse yourself in a real-life murder mystery!
If you made it through this list and you're still craving more, check out our list of the 10 best mystery movies on Netflix.